Advertising - CathNews New Zealand https://cathnews.co.nz Catholic News New Zealand Sun, 22 Sep 2024 02:35:09 +0000 en-NZ hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.1 https://cathnews.co.nz/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/cropped-cathnewsfavicon-32x32.jpg Advertising - CathNews New Zealand https://cathnews.co.nz 32 32 70145804 Advertising from Hell: how a pizza brand's marketing reveals NZ's shifting religious attitudes https://cathnews.co.nz/2024/09/23/ads-from-hell-how-a-pizza-brands-marketing-reveals-nzs-shifting-religious-attitudes/ Mon, 23 Sep 2024 06:11:10 +0000 https://cathnews.co.nz/?p=176038 advertising

Controversial advertising holds a mirror up to society. It can unite us in laughter or outrage, spark debates that shape our beliefs - and sometimes expose our political differences. But where do lines of acceptability or offensiveness get drawn? Earlier this year the New Zealand Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) announced the most complained about ads Read more

Advertising from Hell: how a pizza brand's marketing reveals NZ's shifting religious attitudes... Read more]]>
Controversial advertising holds a mirror up to society. It can unite us in laughter or outrage, spark debates that shape our beliefs - and sometimes expose our political differences.

But where do lines of acceptability or offensiveness get drawn? Earlier this year the New Zealand Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) announced the most complained about ads ever.

Categories ranged from political advocacy to household products. And the most complained about spot belonged to Hell Pizza's "Lust condom" mailers. The brand's "Hell Crossed Buns" billboard came in third.

This is not surprising, given the brand is often in the headlines for its provocative campaigns. Controversy is clearly part of the marketing strategy.

But while multiple complaints might suggest widespread public criticism, our research wanted to test the changing relationship between religious belief and advertising standards: what offends New Zealanders, what pushes the boundaries, and when does an ad cross the line of "acceptable" controversy?

Religious offence vs artistic freedom

Of the 79 ASA rulings between 2005 and 2021 regarding Hell Pizza, only six were upheld in full, and two were partially upheld. This suggests that while Hell's ads generate strong public reactions, the majority of its advertising follows established guidelines.

About 40 percent of the rulings responded to complaints containing religious objections, but no complaints were upheld on religious grounds.

The complainants often identified as Christian, or said they were commenting on behalf of a religious audience. They described Hell's ads variously as "nothing short of emotional and spiritual abuse", "grossly offensive", "sickening", "distasteful", "discriminatory and insensitive" and "blasphemous".

The ASA acknowledged Hell's ads would naturally weave religious puns and references into their narrative, as humour is part of the company's branding. But it ruled these "align within the boundaries of acceptable humour and satire in a tolerant society".

The "Hell Crossed Buns" billboards racked up 178 complaints. The inclusion of a pentagram was described as "extremely offensive", with the use of a Satanic symbol combined with the ad copy called "blasphemous" - particularly in the lead up to Easter.

The ASA responded that it was "a satirical play on commonly recognised religious imagery, which helped it stay within the bounds of artistic freedom". The complaints were not upheld.

Hell Pizza's 2014 Easter-themed billboard covered in rabbit skin (promoting its "rabbit pizza") also received complaints for being disrespectful to religious groups and vegans.

While acknowledging the billboard might upset children, the ASA said it was "unlikely to cause serious and widespread offence to most people", as rabbits are considered a pest and the skins were sourced from a local meat processor. The complaints were not upheld.

Crossing the line

The ASA has upheld complaints about eight Hell Pizza ads between 2005 and 2021, primarily those focused on profanity, graphic violence, racism or sexual themes, rather than religion.

The "most hated New Zealand campaign in history" was Hell's "Lust" campaign from 2006, when the company delivered condoms to 170,000 homes to promote their Lust pizza.

The outrage mainly centered around the potential for children to be exposed to the unsolicited delivery of a condom. The ASA said that despite the message of safe sex having some merit, the campaign was "likely to offend a number of communities". The complaints were upheld.

But while religion has been the main focus of the complaints against Hell's ads, those that were upheld were not because of religious factors.

In fact, it was the "religious identity" of the pizza franchise that was often cited by the ASA as the reason why the controversial ads weren't breaching advertising standards.

That is, people should expect Hell Pizza campaigns to be dark, edgy and shocking.

Although the brand frequently walks the line between provocative humour and possible offence, the ASA rulings indicate a shift towards supporting artistic freedom - even when religious themes are involved, and especially for brands with a strong, established identity.

Shifting trends and boundaries

This shift reflects changes in New Zealand society: a decline in people self-identifying as Christian, an increasing number self-identifying as agnostic or not religious, and those who do identify as religious belonging to a more diverse range of faiths.

Hell Pizza has successfully tapped into this cultural trend by pushing boundaries that previously might have sparked even more outrage.

The brand has also mastered the art of grabbing attention and media coverage that would have been impossible with only traditional paid-advertising techniques.

By inciting public debate, generating complaints and making headlines, it has built a brand identity that thrives on the backlash, using it to fuel further visibility and discussion.

How the strategy works when applied to social issues in an increasingly polarised world remains to be seen.

But Hell's recent "Go to Hell Greta" billboards in Stockholm, as well as its blood-based "to-meat-o sauce" and "AfterLife Pay" offerings, suggest the company will continue to push boundaries.

How religious complaints compare to ones concerned with other social issues, and what this tells us about changing moral and ethical attitudes, will be the focus of our next research project.

  • First published in The Conversation
  • Dan Fastnedge is a Lecturer in Advertising and Brand Creativity, Auckland University of Technology
  • Melissa L Gould is the Head of Critical Media Studies and Senior Lecturer, Auckland University of Technology

Advertising from Hell: how a pizza brand's marketing reveals NZ's shifting religious attitudes]]>
176038
Facebook axes discriminatory ads, will re-educate advertisers https://cathnews.co.nz/2018/08/30/facebook-advertising-discrimination/ Thu, 30 Aug 2018 08:06:34 +0000 https://cathnews.co.nz/?p=111171

Discriminatory ads will soon be a thing of the past with Facebook. Facebook said it has removed more than 5,000 ad-targeting categories to limit the ability of advertisers to exclude users based on ethnicity or religion. Until now, when an advertiser created an ad for Facebook, a tab "to exclude persons who correspond more or Read more

Facebook axes discriminatory ads, will re-educate advertisers... Read more]]>
Discriminatory ads will soon be a thing of the past with Facebook.

Facebook said it has removed more than 5,000 ad-targeting categories to limit the ability of advertisers to exclude users based on ethnicity or religion.

Until now, when an advertiser created an ad for Facebook, a tab "to exclude persons who correspond more or less to the following criteria" allowed for the audience to be filtered based on terms such as "halal," "Islamic vocabulary" or "Shariah."

These terms have now been eliminated.

Advertisers will now have to go through a process of certification to educate them on the "difference between acceptable ad targeting and ad discrimination," Facebook wrote in a blog post on Tuesday.

Facebook France communications representative, Ben Puygrenier, says the religious aspect of the advertising targeting criteria was significant.

"Most targeting options allowed advertisers to identify and exclude ethnic and religious groups," he said.

"Hence, by blocking people interested in the Jewish feast of the Passover, an advertiser could prevent Jewish web surfers from seeing certain ads," he explained.

Facebook is popular among advertisers because it gives them access to an audience of 2.2 billion users and allows them to slice and dice that audience with precision, so they can reach the exact people they're looking for.

But offering such precise targeting to its advertising customers left Facebook exposed to various forms of manipulation, necessitating the current review of its policies and practices.

Source

Facebook axes discriminatory ads, will re-educate advertisers]]>
111171
Church loses lawsuit over Christmas advertising https://cathnews.co.nz/2018/08/02/church-lawsuit-metro-advertising/ Thu, 02 Aug 2018 08:06:49 +0000 https://cathnews.co.nz/?p=109984

The Church has lost a lawsuit challenging the Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority's (WMATAs) advertising policies. The lawsuit was lodged last year by the Washington Archdiocese after the transit company rejected the Christmas advertisement (ad) the Archdiocese wanted to put on a bus. The ad showed silhouetted images of the three wise men and a Read more

Church loses lawsuit over Christmas advertising... Read more]]>
The Church has lost a lawsuit challenging the Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority's (WMATAs) advertising policies.

The lawsuit was lodged last year by the Washington Archdiocese after the transit company rejected the Christmas advertisement (ad) the Archdiocese wanted to put on a bus.

The ad showed silhouetted images of the three wise men and a message to "find the perfect gift" in the Catholic church.

The WMATA said the ad violated the First Amendment and pointed to its policy and guidelines about issue-oriented ads, where political, religious and advocacy ads are all banned.

Guideline 12 specifically bars ads that "promote or oppose any religion, religious practice, or belief."

Challenging this perspective, the Archdiocese said guideline 12 violated the First Amendment and the Religious Freedom Restoration Act.

It asked that WMATA accept the ad and requested the court reject key portions of the company's ban on issue-oriented ads.

The judge's decision was in favour of the transport company: "WMATAs advertising space is a non-public forum," and therefore the First Amendment argument does not apply.

At the same time, the judge said so long as WMATA rejects ads from or against all religions (and groups espousing secularism), the company's decision is not a violation of the First Amendment.

The WMATA policies were implemented after an Islamophobic activist submitted an ad that showed an image of the prophet Muhammad.

Source

Church loses lawsuit over Christmas advertising]]>
109984
Archbishop Dew signs Call for Action on Alcohol statement https://cathnews.co.nz/2014/06/06/archbishop-dew-signs-call-action-alcohol/ Thu, 05 Jun 2014 19:01:36 +0000 http://cathnews.co.nz/?p=58764

Archbishop John Dew, of Wellington New Zealand, is one 37 community leaders who have signed the Call for Action on Alcohol statement, asking for new laws to restrict the sale of alcohol. Among them are representatives from medical colleges and organisations, universities, churches, the Heart Foundation and the Cancer Society. The petitioners have identified four Read more

Archbishop Dew signs Call for Action on Alcohol statement... Read more]]>
Archbishop John Dew, of Wellington New Zealand, is one 37 community leaders who have signed the Call for Action on Alcohol statement, asking for new laws to restrict the sale of alcohol.

Among them are representatives from medical colleges and organisations, universities, churches, the Heart Foundation and the Cancer Society.

The petitioners have identified four priority actions:

  • Phase out alcohol advertising
  • Phase out alcohol sponsorship
  • Institute a minimum unit price for alcohol
  • Increase the tax on alcohol

"This Call for Action has resulted from concern about the continuing damage alcohol misuse is causing too many New Zealanders" says Dr Geoff Robinson, medical spokesperson for Alcohol Action NZ, which has led the initiative.

"Current evidence supports the effectiveness of these four actions to reduce the levels of violence, abuse, illness and addiction that result from the way New Zealanders are drinking," says Professor Jennie Connor, another medical spokesperson of Alcohol Action NZ.

"The group estimates that close to 1000 deaths a year occur in New Zealand due to alcohol abuse and that a quarter of Kiwis over the age of 15 "have a sustained pattern of problematic drinking".

The Auckland City Council has recently proposed some law changes regarding the purchase and use of alcohol.

Peter Lyons writing in the New Zealand Herald describes the proposed changes as "a policy that fails to address the underlying issues around alcohol abuse."

"The proposed local alcohol policy for Auckland City involves a move back to setting closing times. Outer-city drinking establishments will close at 1am whereas inner-city establishments will all close at 3am."

"This will create an interesting meet-and-greet environment for door staff in inner-city bars around this time. Watches will need to be synchronised to prevent bitter disputes. It is a policy that could be described as back to the future."

"The real culprits in the damage caused by excessive alcohol consumption are the alcohol producers and distributors and the off-licence retail outlets."

"The pubs, nightclubs and other drinking establishments are the unwitting victims of very effective lobbying at the national level. This is now being played out in local government alcohol policies," said Lyons

Peter Lyons, an economics teacher at St Peter's College in Auckland

Source

Archbishop Dew signs Call for Action on Alcohol statement]]>
58764
Powershop - seems it is OK to offend Catholics but not the Chinese https://cathnews.co.nz/2013/03/22/powershopseems-it-is-ok-to-offend-catholic-but-not-the-chinese/ Thu, 21 Mar 2013 18:29:46 +0000 http://cathnews.co.nz/?p=41959

Auckland Transport has pulled an advertisement depicting Chairman Mao performing the Gangnam Style dance. It has been banned from Auckland bus stops for fear it will insult Chinese residents. The advertisement for online electricity store Powershop shows the Chinese former dictator surrounded by Chinese people and soldiers posing with guns, and carries the slogan 'Same Read more

Powershop - seems it is OK to offend Catholics but not the Chinese... Read more]]>
Auckland Transport has pulled an advertisement depicting Chairman Mao performing the Gangnam Style dance. It has been banned from Auckland bus stops for fear it will insult Chinese residents.

The advertisement for online electricity store Powershop shows the Chinese former dictator surrounded by Chinese people and soldiers posing with guns, and carries the slogan 'Same Power Different Attitude'.

Powershop is the same business that produced an advertisement depicting the Pope at the time, Pope Benedict XVI, officiating at a same sex wedding.

Auckland Transport communications manager Sharon Hunter said as a general rule they did not want to have adverts on shelters that were designed to "shock, offend or be controversial".

"Something which may be funny to one person can easily be offensive to another.

"On this occasion we believed Powershop's advertisement may potentially cause offence to Auckland's Chinese population".

A Blogger on the New Zealand Conservative Website remarks:

"Strange, how potentially offending the Chinese Government (I mean, come on, this is not poking fun at Chinese people - Chairman Mao represents the Chinese Government, not the people!) immediately creates a proactive reaction from the Council-owned company, while as an ad poking fun at the Pope Emeritis (supposedly marrying two men when the Catholic Church is totally against same-sex marriage) who represents almost as many Catholics as Chinese people (1.1 billion vs 1.2 billion) does not result in a ban on that other ad!"

Powershop chief executive Ari Sargent said he was not aware of any official complaints about the advertisement, which has appeared online and on billboards in Auckland and Wellington.

He said previous campaigns had been more likely to cause offence than the Chairman Mao advert. Powershop had received only one complaint through its call centre, and would be asking Auckland Transport to review the decision.

Source

Powershop - seems it is OK to offend Catholics but not the Chinese]]>
41959
Children are being groomed by alcohol companies https://cathnews.co.nz/2013/03/08/children-are-being-groomed-by-alcohol-companies/ Thu, 07 Mar 2013 18:30:26 +0000 http://cathnews.co.nz/?p=40927

Children are being groomed by alcohol companies years before they reach the legal drinking age, through advertising on Facebook, researchers say. Massey University health psychology associate professor Antonia Lyons says checking Facebook was part of their everyday routine and it was used as a platform to organise social events, many of which revolved around drinking. Read more

Children are being groomed by alcohol companies... Read more]]>
Children are being groomed by alcohol companies years before they reach the legal drinking age, through advertising on Facebook, researchers say.

Massey University health psychology associate professor Antonia Lyons says checking Facebook was part of their everyday routine and it was used as a platform to organise social events, many of which revolved around drinking. It was also used to share alcohol-related updates and photos with friends.

Lyons said this information, combined with bar and alcohol brand pages, had normalised the culture of intoxication among young people.

These pages also had games and giveaways that appealed to children and teenagers, Lyons said. "What they're doing is grooming the next generation of drinkers."

Source

 

Children are being groomed by alcohol companies]]>
40927
'Jesus is coming, better get your hair done' advert not offensive https://cathnews.co.nz/2012/05/30/jesus-is-coming-better-get-your-hair-done-advert-not-offensive/ Wed, 30 May 2012 01:02:32 +0000 http://cathnews.co.nz/?p=26540 A barber shop advert showing a picture of Jesus Christ stating 'He is coming....Better get your hair done' has been cleared of offending Christians. The advert for Barber Brown's hair salon, which is based in Bristol but has a string of salons across the southwest of England, featured a photo of Jesus Christ bathed in Read more

‘Jesus is coming, better get your hair done' advert not offensive... Read more]]>
A barber shop advert showing a picture of Jesus Christ stating 'He is coming....Better get your hair done' has been cleared of offending Christians.

The advert for Barber Brown's hair salon, which is based in Bristol but has a string of salons across the southwest of England, featured a photo of Jesus Christ bathed in light.

Text on the press advert stated: "He is coming ... Better get your hair done!"

Two people complained that the advert was offensive to Christians and that the ad 'implied that Jesus would judge people on their outward appearance' and was offensive as it 'depicted the Second Coming as humorous'.

A spokesman for the barber shop said that in the past flyers advertising the hairdressers had been handed to local churches and that most people were 'positive' about the press advert.

They said it was 'not their intention to cause offence' and that the advert was 'meant to be humorous and different rather than offensive'.

The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) today cleared the advert, stating is had not breached guidelines. Continue reading

‘Jesus is coming, better get your hair done' advert not offensive]]>
26540
South Africa bans fallen angels ad https://cathnews.co.nz/2011/11/01/south-africa-bans-fallen-angels-ad/ Mon, 31 Oct 2011 18:31:13 +0000 http://cathnews.co.nz/?p=14813

According to South Africa's national Advertising Standards Authority, a TV commercial for deodorant, featuring angels falling from heaven, is offensive to Christians and it has ordered the ad's removal. The angelic beings are seen tumbling to Earth because they are attracted to a man wearing Axe deodorant. "A viewer who complained to the ASA about the advert Read more

South Africa bans fallen angels ad... Read more]]>
According to South Africa's national Advertising Standards Authority, a TV commercial for deodorant, featuring angels falling from heaven, is offensive to Christians and it has ordered the ad's removal.

The angelic beings are seen tumbling to Earth because they are attracted to a man wearing Axe deodorant.

"A viewer who complained to the ASA about the advert said the suggestion that angels — God's messengers — would literally fall for a man wearing this deodorant was incompatible with his belief as a Christian," reported the Times of South Africa daily newspaper.

"The advert for Axe deodorant depicts winged, attractive women crashing to earth in what appears to be an Italian town, and then being drawn towards and sniffing a young man who has used the deodorant. The text at the end of the ad reads: 'Even angels will fall,'" reported the Times.

"As such, the problem is not so much that angels are used in the commercial, but rather that the angels are seen to forfeit, or perhaps forego their heavenly status for mortal desires," ruled the ASA. "This is something that would likely offend Christians in the same manner as it offended the complainant."

Sources

South Africa bans fallen angels ad]]>
14813